Celtic Football Club issued a very strong statement on 13th August, demanding full clarification of a decision by their Safety Advisory Group not to permit at present their planned installation of rail seats.Celtic more determined than ever after frustrating safe standing setback
The club said in its statement
: "we believe the proposals we have made would significantly enhance safety at matches. This is a vitally important spectator-safety issue
." The decision, Celtic told their supporters, left them "extremely disappointed and concerned
" and advised that "in an attempt to seek clarity on this matter, we have requested a full written explanation for the judgement made
Happily, it appears that the Safety Advisory Group had no concerns about the safety of fans standing behind rail seats (and why would they, as it is clearly safer than the current practice of standing behind conventional seats!).
So what were their grounds for rejecting Celtic's proposals?
Remarkably, it would appear to be that they recognised that the rail seating area will be very popular (and no doubt they are right there!) and were worried about fans from adjacent areas of conventional seating moving across into the rail seating section and making it overcrowded. Celtic proposed to manage this through the use of stewards (as is seen, for exmaple, between home and away fans in many Premier League grounds), but for the SAG this seemed to be inadequate, as a spokesperson told the BBC website
: "It is the view of agencies on the safety advisory group that some form of physical barrier between standing and seating areas is required to ensure that a standing area would be appropriately managed
Given the role that physical structures, aka fences, have played in stadium disasters throughout the world in the past, it may seem to some bizarre to see a safety authority calling for their introduction in this scenario.
However, as the Herald Scotsman
reported, "The Safety Advisory Group - chaired by Glasgow City Council - has, however, not ruled out the principle of installing rail seating at Celtic Park
", saying that "A spokesman for the safety group, made up of agencies including police and the fire service, indicated the proposal could be reconsidered if issues including proper segregation and increased stewarding were addressed
Given that the club is so determined and that the council evidently agrees that standing behind rail seats is the safer option for the club's standing fans, one can but hope that they and the club will soon reach agreement on how to kerb the enthusiasm of fans elsewhere in the ground for the exciting safe standing experience!
With support from all parties, the National Assembly for
Wales has overwhelmingly passed a resolution in support of safe standing. The
‘Individual Members Debate’ was tabled by Assembly Members Andrew
RT Davies, Ann Jones, Bethan Jenkins, and
Aled Roberts following a visit by the FSF and the Safe StandingRoadshow to The Senedd in June.
Welsh Assembly passes historic safe standing vote
proposal in front of the Assembly was that it:
· Notes the
overwhelming appetite amongst football supporters for the introduction of safe
· Calls on
the Welsh Government to work closely with sport associations and regulatory
authorities to promote safe standing at sports stadia in Wales;
· And calls
on the UK Government to consider the introduction of a pilot of safe standing
resounding vote of 26 in favour, 1 against and 20 abstentions was equivalent to
a vote of 282 for and 11 against at Westminster.
It was gratifying
to see that nearly all of the AMs were well informed about rail seating and
understood its fundamental difference to old-fashioned terracing. Only one AM
appeared to think that what was being proposed was a return to the days of ‘surging’
and ‘charging’, as he put it. It is to be hoped, therefore, that if Westminster
MPs also take the time to inform themselves about rail seating, a similar
outcome might be expected in any future Commons debate.
In the meantime, as the relevant legislation is not a devolved matter,
Welsh Assembly Members will now deliver an open letter to Sports Minister Helen
Grant urging her to introduce a pilot scheme in Wales and to remove legislation
that they say “unfairly stigmatises football fans”.
The full 40-minute debate can be viewed here.
First ever rail seats installed in the UK
2014. A red letter day for rail
seats and safe standing. The first ever block of rail seats in the UK is
unveiled at Bristol City’s Ashton Gate Stadium. Small, but perfectly formed,
the block will be used for demonstration purposes to show interested parties
what rail seats are and how they can be used.
Bristol Sport, which is redeveloping Ashton Gate for use by
both Bristol City and Bristol Rugby Club, is planning to incorporate two areas
of rail seats in the remodelled stadium. Until such time as the rules on
standing at football change, these will offer standing accommodation for
rugby games only and be used as seats for football.
To explain these
plans to key stakeholders, the media and the general public, Bristol Sport has
installed 3 rows of rail seats, totalling 33 in all, in one self-contained
corner of Ashton Gate (now ‘out of bounds’ for football). The
installation was filmed and a timelapse recording of the 6-hour process was
viewed over 5,000 times within the first 24 hours of the official unveiling by
John Leech MP, the Liberal Democrat spokesman on culture, media and sport.
A further 5-minute video was also made for seating
manufacturer Ferco Seating, explaining the technical aspects of the
installation process. It also points out that three rows of seats have three
different rail heights, i.e. 800, 950 and 1100mm, in order to promote debate
about the most appropriate height for the rail integrated into this new form of
Anyone wishing to view the rail seats at Ashton Gate can
arrange to do so by contacting email@example.com
February 6th 2014. In a landmark development for the safe standing campaign it
was announced at the Football League meeting that the League executive had been mandated by the member clubs to “approach
the Minister for Sport to request that the 'all-seater' stadia requirement for
Championship clubs be reviewed with a view to the re-introduction of standing
Football League clubs say 'Yes' to safe standing
This announcement came as the clubs were told how they had
replied to the four questions put to them in the consultation paper
on standing, which had been circulated in late 2013. 78% of clubs
responding to the key question on approaching the government to seek a review
of the law had said ‘Yes’.
The clubs also gave the League executive a mandate
to “approach the Sports Grounds Safety Authority to request that rail
seating products be licensed in Football League grounds
.” The clubs also
replied ‘Yes’ to two further questions, namely: ‘Should clubs be permitted
to accommodate supporters in rail seating in the Championship?
’ and ‘Should
clubs be permitted to revert from seating to standing accommodation in League
One and League Two following relegation from the Championship?
This whole process at the Football League had been initiated
by Bob Symns, Chief Executive of Peterborough United, who came with us to
Hanover to see their rail seats in the summer of 2012 and put a motion in
support of safe standing to a meeting of Championship clubs in February 2013
and to the full League AGM in May 2013.
Welcoming the latest news, Bob said:
“Following all the hard work and commitment that has been undertaken by the
FSF, Safe Standing Roadshow and teams from the Football League and Premier
League in regard to rail seating, I think the result of the safe standing
consultation will prove to be a significant, sensible and safe step in the
right direction on the road to bringing this extremely credible option to the
public and our stadia.”
Bob Symns (second from left) among the rail seats at the ground of Hannover 96
The Football League executives are now expected to
begin discussions with DCMS and the SGSA in line with the mandates given to
them by their member clubs.
December 2013. The safe standing campaign took a major step forward as the Football League sent out a safe standing consultation document to all 72 clubs, seeking their responses to four key questions.Football League asks clubs 4 safe standing questions
The document was the results of many months of researching the safe standing issue by the Football League executive team in response to the vote by 55 of the 72 clubs at their AGM in May that charged the executive with exploring what steps would be necessary to implement safe standing trials.
Having explored this thoroughly, including by making a fact-finding visit to Germany, the executive team were now asking the clubs four questions:- Should the Football League approach the minister for sport to request that the 'all-seater' stadia requirement for Championship clubs be reviewed with a view to the re-introduction of standing accommodation?
- Should the Football League approach the Sports Grounds Safety Authority to request that rail seating products be licensed in Football League grounds?
- Should clubs be permitted to accommodate supporters in rail seating in the Championship?
- Should clubs be permitted to revert from seating to standing accommodation in League One and League Two following relegation from the Championship?
Clubs have been asked to respond by Friday 24th January.
The sort of rail seating on which the League is seeking clubs' views.
Among the clubs already to have responded positively are: Portsmouth
, Derby County
, Bristol City
, Peterborough United
, Exeter City
and Yeovil Town
Others have indicated confidentially that they are answering 'Yes' to all four questions, but have not yet made this public. Still others are consulting their fans.Act now! Contact your club today!
Supporters of Football League clubs that have not yet indicated how they intend to respond are being urged by the Football Supporters Federation
to contact their club urgently via their Supporter Liaison Officer to urge them to reply 'Yes' on all four counts. A list of SLOs' e-mail addresses can be found here
December 2013. Even before obtaining responses from groups from all clubs, BBC Radio One's Newsbeat programme reported that supporters' groups from more than half of all Premier League clubs say they would like the option to stand at football.BBC Radio One Newsbeat join us at VfL Wolfsburg
The report was backed up by photos and video produced by reporter Ben Mundy when we arranged for him to meet us at VfL Wolfsburg a few weeks earlier. With SLO Holger Ballwanz, press officer André
Hahn and stadium manager Thomas Franke playing great hosts, Ben was shown around the stadium and the rail seating area behind the goal for the home fans.
In that area, bathed in bright sunshine, he filmed a piece with Thomas that explains very nicely in little more than a minute just how safe standing at rail seats works and why Thomas would recommend it for grounds in the UK.
Click image to go to video
Many thanks once again to Holger, André and Thomas for all their help on the day!
Recent months have seen safe standing featured on Liverpool fan websites and in items produced by prominent Liverpool fans on TV and in the mainstream press. In November 2013, for instance, major fans' website 'This is Anfield
' began a series of featured articles on the safe standing debate.Liverpool fan sites cover safe standing debate
After regular contributor John Ritchie had set the ball rolling with a piece entitled 'Liverpool FC: The case for safe standing
', our own Jon Darch contributed an article looking at the social background to the standing ban
and suggesting that to support a ban based on the premise that fans who like to stand are trouble waiting to happen was an insult to the 96. Jon also contributed a set of safe standing FAQs
for the site.
More recently, 'This is Anfield' has added a further piece by Peter Caton, author of 'Stand Up, Sit Down
', arguing that to assert that standing is unsafe harms the fight for justice
, a view with which Sheila Coleman of the Hillsborough Justice Campaign appears to agree:
It is very encouraging and interesting to see such Liverpool websites and individuals carry / link to such articles, which were preceded in the late summer by a safe standing video feature for BT Sport
produced by Times football editor and long-standing Liverpool fan Tony Evans and followed in January 2014 by an article by Evan's Times colleague and fellow Reds fans Tony Barrett in The Times and on Liverpool fan site The Anfield Wrap
, in which he asserted that safe standing deserves calm consideration
Never let it be said, therefore, that all in Liverpool are against standing. Clearly that is not the case.
The safe standing campaign received a boost in early October 2013, when new Manchester United CEO Ed Woodward told fanzine 'United We Stand
' that the club was interested in safe standing.Man Utd CEO says club will look at safe standing
"Standing is something we'll look at
," Woodward told fanzine editor Andy Mitten. "I can definitely see the appeal of the German model
Mitten and United fans had a chance to try out that 'German model' for themselves just a couple of weeks later when the club played at Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League. Supporter Liaison Officer Franky Linde showed a group of supporters' representatives and media around the away section of the ground before the match. Fitted with red rail seats it got the thumbs up from all present. Later it helped the United fans generate a great, non-stop atmosphere as the team beat Bayer Leverkusen 5-0 (sorry Franky!).
Atmosphere, indeed, was one of the benefits that Woodward had recognised standing could enhance:
"You can still have an amazing atmosphere at Old Trafford... Standing can make a difference though
Let's hope it's not long before United fans can make that difference standing behind rail seats at Old Trafford!
: Front row from left to right: Ian Stirling (chairman, IMUSA), Duncan Drasdo (chief exec., MUST), Andy Mitten (editor, UWS), Franky Linde (SLO, Bayer Leverkusen)
Bristol, June 2013. Bristol City look set to become the first club in the UK to incorporate safe standing rail seat areas into their ground. That's what will happen if a proposed £40m development of Ashton Gate goes ahead. And the new rail seat areas could be open and in use by August 2015.Bristol City to pioneer safe standing rail seats
This is where I have to declare an interest: Bristol City is the club I've supported all my life, so I'm delighted to see them leading the way as the first club in the UK to propose a stadium development that incorporates rail seats.
The only sad thing about the plans is that unless the rules change between now and August 2015 only supporters of the club's new groundshare partners, Bristol Rugby, will be allowed to stand at the rail seats. For football games the stadium will still have to offer only "seated accommodation", so the rail seats will be unlocked to enable them to be used as seats.
Bristol Sport, the parent company that owns the football and rugby clubs, have provided for 3,152 rail seats in a refurbished Dolman Stand (opposite the dug-outs) and a new end stand (pictured above) that will replace the Wedlock Stand (in part of which away fans are currently housed). Once completed, Ashton Gate will hold 26,500 in all-seater mode and up to 29,000 with standing in rail seat areas.
As indicated above, however, only Bristol Rugby Club will be able to offer the rail seats in standing mode, as current legislation prohibits clubs with all-seater grounds from converting any part back into a standing area, even if, like Bristol City, they have dropped down below the Championship and would otherwise be allowed to offer standing.Inconsistent and illogical legislation
The inconsistent, illogical nature of current legislation is perfectly highlighted here – the authorities are perfectly happy to allow standing in rail seated areas, so long as the ball is oval, not round! However, this shouldn’t detract from the pioneering proposals put forward by Bristol City, who will be lobbying for the redeveloped Ashton Gate (pictured right looking from the Atyeo Stand) to be used as a pilot site for a safe standing trial. These plans come hot on the heels of the vote passed by 55 out of the 72 Football League clubs recently at their AGM, where they approved a motion to “explore the steps necessary” to run safe standing trials.Rail seat areas to open August 2015
The redevelopment plans for Ashton Gate run alongside an exisiting proposal to build a new ground at nearby Ashton Vale, the design of which also includes provision for rail seats. An inquiry into those plans opens in October with the club aiming to decide on which project to proceed with by the end of the year. If they decide to redevelop Ashton Gate, work is scheduled to begin in the spring of 2014 and the new home end and refurbished Dolman Stand (left in the picture above) are set to open in August 2015.
Safe standing video
Portugal. June 7th 2013. The day a vast majority of the 72 Football League clubs passed a vote on safe standing trials and called on their board to explore what steps were necessary to put such trials in place.League AGM passes safe standing vote
As Robin Scott-Elliot reported in The Independent
: "The Football League board is to explore what steps need to be taken in order to hold trials of safe-standing areas within grounds. Pressure is growing on the League after a majority of its member clubs backed a motion in support of the issue at their annual general meeting in Portugal
It is understood that over three-quarters of the League clubs voted in support of the motion. The Independent goes on to say: "There is an expectation the League will "start lobbying in the right places", according to one chief executive, who added that Greg Clarke, the League's chairman, had told him "we will make enquiries". "It's got the will of the people," said the chief executive
This vote comes hard on the heels of 21 out 22 Championship clubs supporting a motion
put forward by Bob Symns of Peterborough United in February, proposing that: "The Football League would encourage and support the instigation of a rail seat/safe standing trial period at any League club wishing to run such a trial. This permission would only apply during a new build or stadium redevelopment
.". Following this second vote among the full 72 clubs, The Independent says that: "The League promised to report to members on what course is open
View again our video that explains all you ever need to know about safe standing at rail seats in under 4 minutes: